FROM CHALKBOARD TO SCREEN: COMPARING DIGITAL AND CONVENTIONAL LEARNING
KAMOLOVA MASHHURA DILMUROD QIZI
1st year student of the Faculty of English Philology of the Uzbekistan State World Languages University
Abstract As a result of technological development, learners can have access to the education not only by face-to-face interaction with teachers, but also through e-learning. This study aims to compare the effectiveness, advantages and limitations of traditional classroom education and online learning. The research highlights key differences between digital educational approach and conventional learning methods in accessibility, flexibility, interaction and academic outcome.
Key words: conventional education, traditional classroom learning, virtual learning, digital educational approach, learning effectiveness, student engagement, academic performance, learning outcomes.
Annotatsiya Texnologik rivojlanish natijasida o‘quvchilar ta’lim olish imkoniyatiga nafaqat o‘qituvchilar bilan yuzma-yuz muloqot orqali, balki elektron o‘qitish (e-learning) vositasida ham ega bo‘ldilar. Ushbu tadqiqot an’anaviy sinfda o‘qitish va onlayn ta’limning samaradorligi, afzalliklari hamda cheklovlarini taqqoslashga qaratilgan. Tadqiqot raqamli ta’lim yondashuvi va an’anaviy o‘qitish usullari o‘rtasidagi asosiy farqlarni — ta’limning mavjudligi, moslashuvchanlik, o‘zaro aloqadorlik va o‘quv natijalari nuqtayi nazaridan — yoritib beradi.
Kalit so‘zlar: an’anaviy ta’lim, sinfda o‘qitish, virtual o‘qitish, raqamli ta’lim yondashuvi, ta’lim samaradorligi, talaba faolligi, akademik ko‘rsatkichlar, o‘quv natijalariАннотация В результате технологического развития учащиеся получили возможность получать образование не только через личное взаимодействие с преподавателями, но и посредством электронного обучения (e-learning). Данное исследование направлено на сравнение эффективности, преимуществ и ограничений традиционного обучения в классе и онлайн-образования. В работе подчеркиваются ключевые различия между цифровым образовательным подходом и традиционными методами обучения в аспектах доступности, гибкости, взаимодействия и академических результатов.
Ключевые слова: традиционное образование, обучение в классе, виртуальное обучение, цифровой образовательный подход, эффективность обучения, вовлеченность студентов, академическая успеваемость, результаты обученияIntroduction Education has undergone significant changes in recent years, driven by advancements on technology and the increasing availability of digital tools. traditional classroom education has been the cornerstone of formal learning for centuries, however, e-learning which includes online courses, virtual classes and digital platforms, is becoming prevalent. Since learners can access to diverse resources and able to learn independently in flexible schedule due to the unique benefits provided by e-learning.
Despite its advantages, there are some concerns, remained regarding student motivation, class engagement and the quality of academic education in online environment. Therefore, by investigating advantages and downsides of these two learning methods, the study informs educators and learners for optimal learning strategies in the 21st century.
The transformation in the education system
Over the years, educational education has experienced remarkable change from traditional classroom learning which relies heavily on chalkboards, physical classrooms and face-to face interaction to computer-based instruction that contains online platforms, courses and virtual communication tools. Students are no longer passive recipients of information when the new form of learning, e-learning, that uses technology for teaching and learning is introduced as a result of the digital revolution. Especially, during the pandemic, online learning has made it possible for students to continue their education. For example, in Pakistan the popularity of online teaching increased during the COVID-19 pandemic.(1) In this case, online platforms such as Zoom, Google classroom, Moodle have played crucial role to gain knowledge.
Even when the questionnaire went on to show the importance of the Moodle system as an e-learning platform, students mentioned that the Moodle Learning Management System (LMS) helped them to improve their study skills(2) However, while e-learning offers a number of advantages, some concerns about discipline, learning quality and unequal access to technology is still remaining.
Changing roles of teachers and students
In the traditional classrooms, teachers play the main role as authority figures. Learning atmosphere is shaped by their experiences and direction, human interaction, instant feedback and face-to face communication. Students, in turn, are supposed to attend the class in person, follow the instructions given by educators. In virtual environment, on the other hand, teacher`s role loses its significance, becomes more of a mentor. Learners, meanwhile, become more independent, active participants and tend to do self-study-searching new information, guide themselves in navigating online resources, taking part in online forums, and most importantly, learn self-organization and time management. Therefore, today, most educators support blended learning which combines classroom experiences with online tools.
Accessibility and learning opportunities
One of the strongest benefits of e-learning is its flexibility. Learners can access courses from anywhere in the world as long as they have an internet connection. This opens doors for people who live in remote areas or cannot attend regular schools because of work or financial problems. In this case, distance learning can be seen as the obvious solution for remote learners. Regardless of geographical distance, any access difficulties can be overcame by the help of online media.
(3) Since, online platforms can offer a wide variety of subjects and global collaboration among students. Information can be updated easily, making learning materials more current and diverse. In one of the studies, 61% of students responded that cyber learning allows easy access to content.
(4)However, these conveniences are not equally available to everyone. Students in rural or economically challenged regions may face difficulties related to poor internet service or lack of digital devices. The lack of IT related knowledge when online classes are conducted is the greatest difficulty which faced by a number of students.
(5) For that reason, the digital divide remains a major issue that limits the effectiveness of online learning. Additionally, one of the studies showed that some did not prefer online education due to the lack of concentration and non-verbal communication.(6) Traditional education, though limited by location, offers equal classroom conditions once students are present. In that sense, traditional schools still play an important role in ensuring social equality in education.
Conclusion
Both systems have advantageous sides: in-person education provides direct interaction, emotional connection and social development, while digital educational approach offers several opportunities such as flexibility, personalized instruction and easy access to the education. That is why, it is not about choosing the better system for improving academic performance, but the goal should be combining their strengths to achieve academic success. Because the combination of both formats is important in increasing the effectiveness of education.(7)
References: Sumia Fatima, Tayyaba Idrees, Sidra Hamid, Muhammad Umar. A Comparative Study of Online and Traditional (Face-to-Face) Learning. Journal of Rawalpindi Medical Collage(JRMS); 2022. https://doi.org/10.37939/jrmc.v26i4.1710
K.D.V. Prasad, Shyamsunder Chitta, Hariprasad Soni. A comparative analysis of traditional and electronic learning systems and their applications in new education system. Multidisciplinary Science Journal. 2023. DOI:10.31843/multiscience.2023060
Commentary: Many Students in Developing Countries Cannot Access Education Remotely | The University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy. Available from: https://harris.uchicago.edu/news-events/news/commentary-many-students-developing-countries-cannot-access-education-remotelySumia Fatima, Tayyaba Idrees, Sidra Hamid, Muhammad Umar. A Comparative Study of Online and Traditional (Face-to-Face) Learning. Journal of Rawalpindi Medical Collage(JRMS); 2022. https://doi.org/10.37939/jrmc.v26i4.1710
Farooq F, Rathore FA, Mansoor SN. Challenges of online medical education in Pakistan during COVID-19 pandemic. J Coll Physicians Surg Pakistan. 2020;30(1):S67–9. Available from: https://doi.org/10.29271/jcpsp.2020.supp1.s67Mukhtar K, Javed K, Arooj M, Sethi A. Advantages, limitations and recommendations for online learning during covid-19 pandemic era. Pakistan J Med Sci. 2020;36(COVID19-S4):S27–31. Available from: https://doi.org/10.12669/pjms.36.COVID19-S4.2785Sharipova Makhmuda Zoitovna. (2024).
EFFECTIVENESS OF ONLINE LEARNING: A COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF TRADITIONAL AND DISTANCE LEARNING. American Journal of Philological Sciences, 4(11), 106–110. https://doi.org/10.37547/ajps/Volume04Issue11-19
I was born on April 8, 2007, in Bukhara, Uzbekistan. I am currently a first-year student at the Faculty of English Philology of the Uzbekistan State World Languages University. Since my early school years, I have been deeply passionate about languages, literature, and communication.
I have always believed that language is a bridge connecting people and cultures. This belief inspired me to study English philology and dedicate myself to improve my language proficiency. I also enjoy exploring the use of technology in education and learning about innovative teaching methods.
In addition to my academic interests, I am an active participant in volunteer and social projects. I value teamwork, kindness, and personal growth. I believe my creative mindset and enthusiasm make me a promising young specialist in my field.
In my free time, I enjoy drawing, expressing my ideas through art and creative activities. I dream of becoming a professional English teacher who inspires students to learn with curiosity, confidence, and joy.
My life motto is: Dream big, work hard and stay humble.